By H. Jefferson Powell

H. Jefferson Powell bargains a robust new method of one of many critical concerns in American constitutional pondering this day: the matter of constitutional law's historicity, or the various ways that constitutional arguments and results are formed either through ancient situations and through the political targets and commitments of varied actors, together with judges. The presence of such impacts is usually thought of hugely problematical: if constitutional legislations is political and historic via and during, then what differentiates it from politics according to se, and what provides it integrity and coherence? Powell argues that constitutional conception has as its (sometimes hidden) time table the ambition of unveiling how constitutional legislations can get away from background and politics, whereas a lot constitutional historical past seeks to spot an traditionally precise which means of the constitutional textual content that, as soon as exposed, can function a corrective to next deviations from that truth.Combining heritage and concept, Powell analyzes a chain of constitutional controversies from 1790 to 1944 to illustrate that constitutional legislation from its very starting has concerned politically charged and ideologically divisive arguments. Nowhere in our previous can one locate the golden age of apolitical constitutional considering good deal of latest scholarship seeks or presupposes. seen over the years, American constitutional legislation is a heritage of political dispute couched in constitutional terms.Powell then takes his conclusions one step extra, claiming that it truly is accurately this old culture of argument that has given American constitutional legislations a notable coherence and integrity through the years. it doesn't matter what the actual political disputes of the day will be, constitutional argument has supplied a shared language by which our political neighborhood has been in a position to struggle out its battles with no eventually fracturing. A group equipped on phrases might be needs to examining for any pupil of constitutional historical past, thought, or legislation.

Show description

Read Online or Download A Community Built on Words: The Constitution in History and Politics PDF

Best constitutional law books

The Language of Liberal Constitutionalism

This publication explores easy questions relating to constitutional idea. First, in view of a dedication to democratic self-rule and frequent confrontation on questions of worth, how is the construction of a valid constitutional regime attainable? moment, what needs to be actual a couple of structure if the regime that it helps is to continue its declare to legitimacy?

The Power of Precedent

The function that precedent performs in constitutional selection making is a perennially divisive topic between students of legislation and American politics. the controversy rages over either empirical and normative elements of the difficulty: To what volume are the perfect courtroom, Congress, and the administrative department limited by way of precedent?

The Conscience of the Constitution: The Declaration of Independence and the Right to Liberty

Is liberty or democracy the first constitutional worth? At a time while american citizens are more and more dealing with violations in their civil liberties, Timothy Sandefur's insightful new publication explains why the announcement of Independence, with its doctrines at the primacy of liberty, the traditional rights of guy, and the boundaries on valid executive, should still function the guidepost for knowing the structure.

Australian Constitutional Landmarks

Highlighting turning issues within the shaping of the Australian country due to the fact that Federation, this assortment examines instances from their criminal and political context, via their implementation and eventual impression on constitutional reform. Contributions by means of famous constitutional legal professionals, judges and former leader justices make sure the worth of the research.

Extra resources for A Community Built on Words: The Constitution in History and Politics

Example text

In the State of Delaware, there are fifty odd thousand free citizens, and what reason can be assigned why a 34 III. 1793: The Supreme Court and the Metaphysics of Sovereignty free citizen who has demands against them should not prosecute them? Can the difference between forty odd thousand, and fifty odd thousand make any distinction as to right? Is it not as easy, and as convenient to the public and parties, to serve a summons on the Governor and Attorney General of Delaware, as on the Mayor or other Officers of the Corporation of Philadelphia?

Jefferson’s own text, in short, implicitly but skillfully affirmed the paramount authority of the constitutional text and in doing so signaled or enacted its (and his) fidelity to the written Constitution. At the same time, however, Jefferson’s opinion hinged on his premise that foreign business is “Executive altogether,” and that assertion is not straightforwardly textual at all. The premise is a possible construction of the text’s meaning in eighteenth-century English, not a necessary one. But that is the most that could have been said for the opposite premise, or indeed any other.

In answering the president’s question, Jefferson strove to fashion a line of reasoning that would invoke or allude to pertinent features of the text of the Constitution: the distribution of the power-granting provisions in Articles I– 19 Part One III; the initial clause of Article II providing that “[t]he executive Power shall be vested in a President”; the location of the provisions concerning the Senate’s advice and consent role within the enumeration of presidential powers in Article II, section 2; the wording of the appointments clause.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.16 of 5 – based on 27 votes